Founded 1950
Committee C4 (HF Matters) Interim Meeting
20-21 April 2013 InterCity Hotel, Vienna
SUBJECT Contest-free 3rd full weekend in October for recruitment of young
radio amateurs via Jamboree-on-the-Air (JOTA)
Society NRRL Country: Norway
Committee: C4 Paper number: VIE13/C4/09
Contact: Tom V. Segalstad, LA4LN e-mail: LA4LN@ARRL.NET
Background
For a number of years we have at IARU Region 1 Conferences and Interim Meetingsdiscussed the possibility of having at least one contest-free weekend on the HF bands. Contests are of course good to show activity and that we use the amateur radio bands ("use them or lose them"). But with 8 - 9 contests per weekend, and the number of contests increasing, we hear from our society members an increasing groan that it has become ever so difficult to find a clear spot on the bands for that pleasant and relaxing non-contest contact during the weekends on the 5 "classic" bands + 160 m – unless they use the contest-free, narrow bands of 30, 17, and 12 meters, with limited propagation.
Jamboree-on-the-Air (JOTA) was established in 1958 by Leslie "Les" Mitchell, G3BHK. A World Scout Jamboree is a camp where scouts from all over the world get together to learn about the world brotherhood of scouting. But it is costly to travel to a World Jamboree, and all the millions of scouts cannot be present at one and the same place. Les realized that many scout leaders were also radio amateurs. And with the help of amateur radio, it would be possible to arrange a Jamboree-on-the-Air.
JOTA has proven to be an enormous success over the years, with thousands of amateur radio stations taking part, bringing together about half a million of boy
scouts and girls scouts and guides from all over the world every year. Many
authorities allow the scouts to operate the radio under the presence and guidance of
the licensed radio amateur.
Amateur radio is also used from national jamborees, smaller scout camps, scout
courses, and other scouting events. Some national scout organizations have their
own committees for amateur radio and "radio scouting", also organizing amateur
radio courses for scouts.
The Norwegian Boy Scout Association established their first "Amateur Radio
Committee" in the late 1960s (with LA5CH as its first chairman). Since that time
more than 500 scouts in Norway have become radio amateurs through this radio scouting program, built around the JOTA event. This constitutes more than 10% of the Norwegian radio amateur census!
There is no exaggeration to say that the JOTA scouting event with amateur radio
is the most effective way to recruit young people to amateur radio. The 55th JOTA was held in October 2012.
Recruitment of young radio amateurs
IARU Region 1 has during the last years made strategies for recruitment of youngradio amateurs. Without active radio amateurs on the amateur radio bands, we may
lose our bands! Hence we need to show the pleasure and fun of amateur radio to
youngsters, in order to recruit them.
If IARU would assign just one weekend every year towards such recruitment, the 3 rd full weekend of October would be ideal, because there already is an annual activity there, JOTA, successfully presenting amateur radio to young people for the last 55 years.
Considerations
The 3rd full weekend of October was selected for JOTA from 1959, because there were no major contests during that weekend. The presence of contests will of courselimit the activities for the scouts, if the scouts should be presented for trying phone,
CW, and digital modes.
How many contests are there per year? In 2012 the [ARRL] Contest Corral database
tracks 440 different contests. The online WA7BNM and SM3CER contest calendars have even more contests. Of the 440 tracked in Contests Corral, 326 (74%) are HF-
only and 35 (8% ) only use the VHF+ bands. 73% feature CW – the most popular contest mode by nearly 2-to-1 over Phone (46%) and Digital (37%). Even though there are 22 more (new) contests this year, the proportion of CW:Phone:Digital remains almost exactly the same. [From ZS4BS "HF Happenings" No. 530, 9 Nov. 2012]. With 52 weekends per year, this gives us an average of 8 - 9 contests per weekend. There are now 15 different contest on the 3rd full weekend of October. It should here be emphasized that DARC has been extremely cooperative in limiting the band segments for their WAG Contest operation the 3 rd weekend of October. But we all know that IARU bandplan segments and contest-regulated segments are not obeyed during the heat of contests.
Contests are absolutely not in the interest of scouts in JOTA, and contests will therefore be counter-productive in trying to catch their interest for amateur radio. A
spin-off from JOTA could be that amateur radio societies ask the scouts for help other times during field-day operations (logistics, tower building, logging help, and so on) to further catch their interest in radio and technology.
Scouts also have a focus on emergency preparedness. It could be fruitful if collaboration was sought between scouts and radio amateurs for emergency preparedness.
Existing recommendations
IARU Region 1 made the following recommendation at the Cavtat Conference in2008, based on a paper from NRRL:
CT08_C3_Rec 24: (Paper CT08_C3_39)
In recognizing the importance of the JOTA for radio amateur recruiting, it is
recommended that Member Societies encourage radio amateurs to assist boy
scouts and girl guides to participate in the annual JOTA the third full weekend
of October each year, organized by the World Organization of the Scout
Movement (WOSM) and to use this opportunity to present amateur radio
recruiting possibilities to the scouts/guides.
It has also been discussed in IARU R1 that existing contests should be joined and
coordinated, in order to reduce the number of contests. This has successfully been
done in the Nordic Countries, e.g., the SAC (Scandinavian Activity Contest), the
NRAU-Baltic Contest, and the NAC (Nordic Activity Contest for VHF/UHF/SHF).
The HF Managers' Handbook (Chapter 12; Contest rules and regulations) specifies
rules for the establishment of new HF contests within the Region, to be enforced by
the Contest Subgroup. This subgroup has been discontinued; although it is assumed
that new contests pop up without applying.
What to do?
It must be emphasized that very few of the contests now arranged the 3 rd full
weekend of October are arranged by IARU member societies. Therefore a resolution
to keep the 3rd full weekend of October free of contests, if accepted by all the IARU
regions, must be presented by IARU to both member societies and to other contest
organizers.
NRRL wants to propose the following recommendation, which can be discussed or
modified at the Interim Meeting:
Recommendation
In recognizing the importance of the JOTA for radio amateur recruiting, it isrecommended that Member Societies and other amateur radio contest
organizers seek to move contests away from the 3 rd full weekend of October, in
order to leave this weekend contest-free. The purpose of this is to encourage
radio amateurs to assist boy scouts and girl guides to participate in the annual
JOTA the third full weekend of October each year, organized by the World
Organization of the Scout Movement (WOSM), and to use this opportunity to
present the full width of amateur radio to the boy scouts and girl guides, as
recruiting possibilities to the scouts/guides.
If a recommendation is agreed on at the Interim Meeting, it is further proposed that
the recommendation be submitted to C3 at the next IARU Region 1 Conference, and
to forward the recommendation to the other IARU regions.
